If you prioritize accessibility, usability, and privacy in front-end development, then Google Analytics is not your friend.
I used to work for a small design/development agency where adding the Google Analytics script to websites served as our stamp of completion before a project was turned over to a client. Even though most clients only used the platform to track page views (or not at all), we always included it because we assumed “they might need it, someday.” That is the same logic you would use to convince yourself not to throw away the pair fingerless gloves from that 80’s office party seven years ago.
Just as you would consider the potential effect that other large third-party packages might have on usability, analytics should not get an automatic pass. Luckily, there are lighter, less invasive ways to track whether your website is meeting its goals.
What makes Google Analytics problematic?
The snippet placed in the
<head> of your markup downloads a larger tracking file totaling around 40kb after gzipping. This causes a noticeable performance hit for viewers using older technology or for those who have a slow internet connection.
It’s overloaded with features that are way beyond what most websites or apps require.
Even larger applications rarely make use of all the features Google Analytics offers. Smaller projects almost definitely will not. And because Google’s analytics scripts are not open source, there is no way to pare down the code to only what is needed for your project.
It’s a privacy disaster.
Google uses its Analytics product, along with others, to determine a user’s browsing path around the internet. By linking that information to an IP address and an associated Google account, a complete profile of a person can be assembled. It’s this information that gives Google its advertising superpower. - Christian Stewart
Options to replace Google Analytics with a more sane solution
1. Remove analytics tracking completely: In some cases, the only piece of data that is actively monitored is user traffic. Some hosting platforms provide visitor metrics by default.
2. Use log analytics: Software exists that can turn your raw server logs into a set of organized statistics with many of the same features as Google Analytics. Take a look at GoAccess as an example.
3. Use an image tracking solution: Image tracking works by placing a small
<img> tag in the HTML of a website. When the browser makes a request to the url set as the
4. Use a different JS tracker: Many analytics options count privacy as one of their priorities. Matomo’s analytics script is half the size of Google Analytics, and being open-source, can be modified to bring the size down even more.
Consider the potential effects overloading your site with trackers might have on the user’s experience. In many cases, there is a lighter alternative to Google Analytics that can provide equivalent data without sacrificing privacy or accessibility.